Alright, look, so the last month has been really difficult, okay. We got behind on some projects. We had couples therapy to miss. We had rehab to skip out on. Jury duty to dodge. Itâs been a whole thing. And to top it off the only person we have on staff who has seen any of these movies got absolutely demolished by a police horse. This horse really messed him up.
Well, unfortunately, this was not a year where brevity translated to success and we really didnât have twenty-plus hours to kill watching all these films. But fortunately⌠we knew someone who did. Our little cousin Nate. Nate is fourteen years old, a high school Freshman and a member of his schoolâs film society. (They just watched âUsual Suspects.â How fun.) Heâs also – thankfully – grounded to his room for blowing up his principalâs mailbox. And so he had a lot of time to review this yearâs ten best picture nominees. Weâre pretty sure he pirated some of the more recent ones, but we didnât ask because people already ruined Soap2Day by talking too much about it.
We asked him if he could do the foreign films, documentaries, and shorts as well. And he told us âcheugyâ and we have no idea what that even means. So without further ado, weâre very proud(?) to present to you this alphabetical list of the 2024 Best Picture noms, as reviewed by a weasel-mustached, acne-covered, Axe-Body-Spray-reeking teenager.
âAmerican Fictionâ
Look, I admit, I know nothing about the publishing industry but I do look at magazine when my mom makes me go to the dentist. I think I get the gist of what this movieâs going for since Iâm in Mrs. Whitmerâs Intro to Creative Writing Class for fourth period right now. It was like really smart, but sometimes I worried it was too smart. Still, Sterling K. Brown was the GOAT in this. Really happy heâs up for an Oscar. Hope he wins, no cap. On the whole, the thing that felt most profound about this movie was that it wasnât called âAfrican American Fiction,â even though thatâs what it was about. It was just âAmerican Fiction.â Because really⌠weâre all Americans. You think about that. I know I did. I give it a 3.5 stars out of 5.
âAnatomy of a Fallâ
I was really nervous because this was a foreign film and I hate having to read the words at the bottom of the screen. I didnât go to the movies to take a test. But it turns out they had the good sense to still do most of the movie in English. And I think thatâs smart, because there was so much talking in this movie. Like this wasnât even a movie. This was a play. You seriously tricked me into watching a play. And plays suck. Like we just had to read âRomeo and Julietâ in English. Fuckinâ lame AF, man. Anyway, the main lady in this was bi and a baddy, which is hot. 4 outta 5.
âBarbieâ
I didnât know what to make of this movie so I listened to Andrew Tateâs podcast and those guys made a lot of good points. Then they talked about cigars and cars and it was lit. But look, Iâm not a misogynist, alright, Iâm pro co-ed sports at my high school. But I think the movie would have been a lot more funny if Adam Sandler made it. I just rewatched âHubie Halloween 2â and bruh, that shit is gas. The best part of “Barbie” is when Ryan Reynolds was a total boss. I give it 2 stars because it was pretty.
âThe Holdoversâ
Holy fucking yes, dude. I actually wasnât expecting to like this. I donât like when people make movies about teenagers, because they never get it right, but I liked this one. I started acting like the main kid Angus around school because heâs like me, for real. Heâs like smart, and his parents suck and heâs independent. Like he can take care of himself. And thatâs like me. I can make pasta by myself. I can walk down to the Chiptole. I can stay home alone without a babysitter even. And anyway, thatâs why I blew up my principalâs mailbox. Because of the movie. 5/5.
âKillers of the Flower Moonâ
Yeah, I gotta be honest, Iâm not sure I could sit through this again. Like donât get me wrong, Scorsese is fire. But this is one where Iâm like⌠bro, just make it a mini-series. This wouldâve been so much easier to take if he had done it in like a couple forty-five minute increments on Netflix. I mean that. Netflix has actually gotten really good lately. Like look at the stuff theyâve got on there like âHubie Halloweenâ parts 1 and 2. Anyway⌠this movieâs great and all. I kinda wish Leo and his lady had ended up together at the end. Like he wasnât a saint, but he ended up doing the right thing, she shouldâve forgiven him. Sometimes itâs nice to have a happy ending. 3.5 hours out of 5.
âMaestroâ
Dude, imagine thinking anyone would care about this movie. I guess Bradley Cooper spent like six years learning how to conduct one piece of music. And thatâs cool and all, but also think about what you could do with six years. He couldâve probably made like⌠three to six other movies about surfing or ninjas or some shit. And they all wouldâve required less work. God, you can just tell he was one of those guys back in school that was always kissing his teachersâ asses. Being like âUm, hey teacher Nate is trying to make himself puke so he doesnât have to take the test.â Like mind your own business dude. This one gets 2.5 out of 5.
âOppenheimerâ
This movie was really fucking cool. Made by the absolute GOAT, Christopher Nolan. Is this my favorite Nolan film? No, I donât think so. I mean, he is my favorite director, so like⌠I love all of his movies, but I like âInceptionâ more. Okay, and the top totally fell, so I donât want to hear anyone arguing about that. Also, I love âInterstellar.â I donât know if any of you have seen it, itâs pretty scientifically complex. Like âRick and Mortyâ youâd really need a certain degree of intelligence to understand it. Thatâs really what this movie felt like it was about. Someone whoâs so smart that other people canât handle it, so they make him into the bad guy. Oh and donât even get me started on âThe Dark Knight.â Is Heath Ledgerâs Joker the greatest performance in film history? I think it might be. 5/5 stars.
âPast Livesâ
MOVIES LIKE THIS ARE WHATâS FUCKING WRONG WITH SOCIETY! I canât⌠Iâm sorry. The main lady in this was SO FUCKING SELFISH. And her husband was such a cuck. Itâs like âoh yeah, your ex-boyfriend from Koreaâs coming in for the weekend. Yeah, thatâs fine, you should totally go out and do a ton of stuff with him and Iâll totally support that.â This is why all the girls in my school are always walking around in short-shorts and nobody says anything, but I got yelled at by my math teacher for wearing an âI hate cats, but I love pussyâ hat. If I ever get a girlfriend she will never treat me like this. HALF A FUCKING STAR.
âPoor Thingsâ
This is kinda similar to âPast Livesâ except⌠I donât know. I mean, the main character is still super selfish and rude. But like, in a funny way. Something was different about it. I canât put my finger on it. Maybe like⌠the director was better. Maybe the cast. Maybe it was just more fun to watch or⌠oh yeah, maybe it was just a more interesting film. Still, Emma Stone is super weird in this. Sheâs probably acoustic. And you know what sucked? Emma Stone is normally really hot. But in this, even though sheâs having lots of sex, she makes absolutely no effort to be hot. Itâs like itâs⌠not for me, almost. Even though itâs really for me. 3.5 out of 5 stars.
âThe Zone of Interestâ
I donât know how many times I need to say it, but⌠NO MORE SUBTITLE MOVIES. I donât know why A24 thinks it can keep getting away with this. Also, how are you gonna make a movie about the Nazis and not show any footage inside the you-know-what camps. What, was this made on like a shoestring budget? Did they not want to spend the money on the extras? All this was just people mumbling and putting on coats. If I wanted to see that, Iâd just go to my granddadâs nursing home. 1.5 out of 5 stars.