Black Flag is a legendary band people love to lie about listening to. Every indie artist name-drops them as an influence, and it’s all for cred. Only like eight people actually listen to Black Flag for enjoyment and you’re in luck because I’m one of them and I’m ranking their discography for you.
7. Family Man (1984)
There are people who claim this album is good. There are also people who say mushrooms on pizza are delicious. I don’t believe either group. You have to sit through 15 minutes of Henry Rollins’ solo abstract ramblings while he was still about 20 years from learning how to tell a story well. And when the music finally starts, it’s not much better. Henry talks over one 9-minute track, then the rest are instrumental jams. Not my cup of hardcore. But the album artwork goes pretty fucking hard, so it deserves credit for that. If you feel the need to buy this one, keep it hung up on the wall. Framed. You’re not a teenager anymore, get a goddamn frame.
Play It Again: the album artwork
Skip It: the music
6. What The… (2013)
Ah, the reverse “Family Man.” “What The…” has artwork so bad, it makes you hate the music more than maybe you should. The artwork is fucking pixelated. And stupid. But the music? It sounds like a fairly competent Black Flag tribute act. In keeping with late Black Flag tradition, the production is shit. Ron Reyes actually sounds pretty lively here, but it’s not enough to sustain interest over the course of twenty-two (22!!!!!) songs. I swear I like this band and will start complimenting them soon, but oof- they sure have laid some turds for me to sift through.
Play It Again: “It’s So Absurd” and “Go Away” are surprisingly decent
Skip It: letting your eyes focus on that bootleg South Park-ass artwork too long
5. In My Head (1985)
If I had a time machine, I would first go back to dropkick the fuck out of Baby Hitler. But my second stop would definitely be 1985 so I could give Greg Ginn a goddamned guitar tuner. Am I losing my mind or are most of the guitar parts here out of tune? Holy shit, nothing sounds right. Maybe it’s some artistic statement against sterile, perfect ‘80s music production trends. Or perhaps I have horseradish and gravel in my ears (very possible). The production is just ugly and not in a cool way, which is a shame because some of the songs on the second half are great. Other tracks have these circling guitar lines that make me physically feel nauseous which is neat as a party trick, but bad as a full album experience.
Play It Again: “In My Head” and “Drinking and Driving” are some of the best latter-day Flag songs
Skip It: “I Can See You” sounds like a kid at Guitar Center practicing their scales through a 100-watt Marshall amplifier. Truly harrowing.
4. Slip It In (1983)
Let’s get this out of the way, the title track which opens the album is pretty gross. I don’t even really know what it’s trying to say. I think it’s slut-shaming? Or coercing? Who knows, I’ve already spent more time thinking about this song than it deserves. The artwork is similarly icky and features a pre-”King of the Hill” Hank Hill as the leg. Thankfully, things improve significantly after the opener and the rest of the album is quintessential Black Flag.
Play It Again: If you don’t like “Black Coffee”, I don’t think you really like punk
Skip It: the title track, yikes
3. Loose Nut (1985)
Throughout 1984 and 1985, Black Flag would release five albums. I’ll say it- that’s too many albums. But somehow, “Loose Nut’ (the fourth of the five) doesn’t find the band fatigued at all. Bassist Kira Roessler crushes it all over this album, which she was doing to pass the time until she could go and win multiple Emmy awards for editing. I’m not lying- go look it up, then feel like shit about what you’ve done with your life. I know I do.
Play It Again: “Modern Man”
Skip It: “This Is Good” would have benefitted from another attempt at that guitar solo
2. My War (1984)
I’ve been ragging on Black Flag pretty hard throughout this ranking for questionable artistic choices. But to be honest, a lot of those decisions required risk and vulnerability. “My War” is one situation where it all panned out successfully. The gang brought an artfulness that could have easily been way too pretentious, but “My War” always thrashes. Things slow down on the back half yet it still kicks all kinds of butthole. And the album artwork terrorized a generation of kids to be afraid of hand puppets. Ok I just made that last fact up but it could be true, I don’t know.
Play It Again: “Scream” which inspired hundreds of thousands of inferior bands
Skip It: “Can’t Decide” has a weird “Baby Shark”-esque quality I can’t really put my finger on
Honorable Mention: The First Four Years (1983)
This collection comprises the singles and EPs released by Black Flag before their debut album “Damaged.” It fucking rules. “Nervous Breakdown” and “Jealous Again” are two of the greatest punk songs of all time. This compilation rules so hard that I wanted to place this at number one. But my editor said “It’s a compilation, not a record, so don’t you fucking dare try to place it in number one or I’ll sneak into your apartment and take a shit in your pillowcases then squeeze the shit log from the outside of the pillowcase so it gets ground into the fabric and is really hard to clean” and folks, I don’t want to clean shit out of my pillowcases.
Play It Again: the whole album
Skip It: shitting in my pillowcases
1. Damaged (1981)
Maybe you thought we were going to be contrarian and put “My War” at the top of the list. Or alienate everyone we love and go with “What The…” but nope. Damaged is a cornerstone of early hardcore for a reason- it fucking rules. Almost overnight, regular Hard Times joke target Henry Rollins went from being the manager of a Häagen-Dazs in D.C. to singing as frontman of punk legends who hadn’t even released a full album yet. His sincerity and energy are on full display here and it works. Oh boy, does it work. In fact, I smashed my glass of iced tea while relistening to it just now and I’m still bleeding but I won’t do anything about it until the album ends.
Play It Again: everything here is a banger
Skip It: seriously, don’t shit in my pillowcase

While Elizabeth’s melee weapon skills were unparalleled, the rules of challenge did not explicitly ban handguns, a fact that Charles exploited in their battle.
He is forbidden to react or even smile.
A bundle handstamp is available
“Okay, let’s shit fuck this monarchy into fucky, sucky… king crown land or… whatever, Fuck!”
The American experiment is at an end. Long Live Chalres III, King of the United States of America!
Proud Gentlemen, stand down and stand by.
Don’t even act like you wouldn’t hit that.
They do them for everything over there.
Kind of a cuck move, bro.
“Quite the gift indeed…”
Go ahead and try, you won’t be able to do it!
“and from Jesus Christ, the faithful witness, the firstborn of the dead, and the ruler of the kings of the earth. To Him who loves us and released us from our sins by His blood.”
Half-off apps and bottomless margaritas to anyone who can prove they are of royal blood!
Honestly, what is the goddamn point?
Real, live, actual fucking QUICHE! Praise God!
Sorry Monroe and Dianna, pappa Eltons’ got checks to cash.
If there’s anyone left out there, know that there is hope.
We’re all legitimately happy that Modest Mouse was making weird music in 2021. But it sucks that it keeps taking 5+ years to get yet another mediocre record. If Captain Isaac and crew put out whatever songs they’d been working on each year, I think fans would be happier than having to wait forever to get a record with a few great songs and a lot of noodling. If I wanted that I’d listen to “Sad Sappy Sucker” and, no, we’re not ranking that one. Maybe the band’s commercial success makes them feel like their releases need to feel important. It’s like the band is being buried alive by their own success. Oh, shit. That album title’s clever.
This would have made a great EP. Or a solid follow-up to “We Were Dead…” if it were released in 2009 maybe. This record has some amazing songs that are on par with anything the band made at their peak. However, this album feels like a band regaining its musical footing after a long break, which is strange because in Isaac Brock’s blog, he said they were hard at work on it the entire time. That was a long eight years of blog-reading, Isaac, and the results were only kind of worth it.
We’ve officially entered into classic Modest Mouse territory. The messy, drunk band of angry-yet-sensitive pioneers of the great hipster front. “Long Drive” is the band’s first official full-length release and it shows you exactly who this band is: wonderfully sloppy. I’d rank this one higher and talk about how groundbreaking it is if Built to Spill hadn’t already put out “There’s Nothing Wrong With Love.”
During an era where signing to a major label almost certainly meant changing your sound, Modest Mouse defied the odds and released this weird-ass masterpiece. This album brings out the softer side of the band, which is ironic because production was halted for months while Isaac Brock recovered from a street fight he got into with a group of dudes. He’s basically the 50 Cent of indie rock, minus the investment skills.
This is the one with Johnny Marr on it. What a fucking coup. There are riffs on here that really feel like a Modest Mouse/Smiths collaboration. This is also the first record they made with members of their wildly talented touring lineup during their most commercially successful period. They also had two drummers, which would have been obnoxious if it didn’t sound so good. It looked pretty silly though. Then again, so did a lot of indie rock at the time. At least they didn’t come on stage in a giant hampster wheel.
Prior to recording this album, Modest Mouse practically broke up and drummer Jeremiah Green left the band. They completely reinvented themselves in the studio to make one final album that would likely be their last. Once again, limitation breeds creativity and “Good News…” was a massive success. Hell, “Float On” even helped make Lupe Fiasco blow up and if anyone deserves success it’s the guy who wrote “Kick, Push.” The second and third tracks have completely different emotional tones to them but they’re the SAME CHORDS. These guys can even make pop music weird and excessively complicated. Fucking indie kings.
This is the perfect Modest Mouse record. It’s indisputable. Objectively, this record has the best lyrics, music, and production. It is flawless in its flaws and perfect in its perfection. It exists exactly as it should be. And now that you’ve read our Modest Mouse rankings, your taste in music has officially leveled up. We’re glad you totally agree with our rankings.