BERKELEY, Calif. — Local punk Tom Reynolds is still unsure which Green Day albums he’s allowed to enjoy publicly while still maintaining his “punk cred,” despite years of independent research, sources confirm.
“My friend Annie said once they went political, they totally sold out, but that everything up to and including Insomniac is all good,” Reynolds recalled. “But this older punk dude said he’s only down with ‘Minnesota Girl’ — which I’d never even heard of — before he went on a Crimpshrine tangent for like, 25 minutes. It felt like the longest bus ride of my entire life.”
Various punks chimed in with differing opinions.
“It’s not that fucking hard — 39/Smooth, Kerplunk!, and that’s it,” said aging punk Sarita Patel. “Anything after they signed to Reprise is straight garbage. Even Dookie.”
Meanwhile, self-described “scene legend” Chad Chernak only confused Reynolds even further. “Ska covers of American Idiot are the only acceptable incarnation of Green Day,” he allegedly claimed.
Ultimately, Reynolds consulted an expert for an official verdict.
“Here’s the thing: if you’re OK with the first two records, you gotta allow everything up to Nimrod. A lot of those songs were written pre-Dookie anyway,” said amateur Green Day historian Adam Lefler, drawing on nearly 30 years of research. “‘Haushinka’ is from like ‘91 or something, for example.”
- Green Day Threatens to Release New Album
- Man Takes Green Day Cover on Two-Week, 17-Guitar Center Tour
- BREAKING: Singer Billy Joel Quits Green Day
“Then you get these pretentious, supposed ‘purists’ who claim to hate Idiot, but it’s just like all the other records… so why wouldn’t you like it?” an increasingly agitated Lefler added. “Plus, 21st was all rip-offs of Warning anyway, so that’s obviously gonna get a pass. I don’t know. It’s not like they put out Ratitude or something. Give them a fucking break.”
Unfortunately, the one final, definitive opinion Reynolds received only gave him even more to think about, still leaving him without a solidified take on the Green Day catalog.
“I mean, I think it’s all good, but obviously pre-21st is the best stuff,” said Green Day frontman Billie Joe Armstrong. “Except the trilogy. That was really awful. Sorry about that.”