SYRACUSE, N.Y. — Local 46-year-old metalhead Rich Dresden nervously concocted a complex narrative to explain to the clerk at Urgent Breakdown Records why he was only now purchasing a physical copy of Slayer’s classic 1986 album “Reign in Blood,” disinterested sources confirmed.
“I used to have a cassette copy that I dubbed from my buddy’s CD in 10th grade,” Dresden muttered in preparation as he paced the aisles with the seminal thrash album tucked under his arm. “Then that got stuck in the tape deck of my car, but that was around the time that Napster really took off, so I was able to download all the tracks, even though half of them said they were Anthrax songs. But yeah, I burned a CD made up of those downloads and had that until it got too scratched, and then I was going to buy the vinyl but I could never find it at my local Target, and I refuse to buy records from Amazon, so yeah, you know. Let’s just hope the cashier doesn’t find any plotholes in my story.”
Urgent Breakdown Records clerk Ashley Browning said that listening to such tales is totally routine in her line of work.
“Yeah, I could see [Dresden] psyching himself up as he fidgeted in the checkout line,” Browning explained while yawning. “And since he was wearing a battle vest with a bunch of metal band patches, I knew exactly what was coming. A few weeks ago, this guy who was probably in his early 50s and was dressed like he was in Williamsburg in 2001 came in to buy the first Arcade Fire record, and I was treated to a soliloquy about how his ex took his original copy when she moved out, and so he had to replace it with this inferior re-press. Weird that all Arcade Fire fans use this identical story.”
Musicologist Fred Erikson, PhD, confirmed that this is a common occurrence.
“People who attach their own sense of identity to music fandom can get caught in a catch-22: They don’t yet own a classic album of their preferred genre, but to obtain one, they have to implicitly admit that they don’t already have it,” said Erikson. “In my last article, I refer to it as The Poser’s Dilemma. To be an expert in a genre, you must know the classics, but unfortunately, to look like an expert you actually can’t purchase the iconic ones publicly. You simply can’t win.”
At press time, Dresden further embarrassed himself by also deciding to buy a copy of Kerry King’s 2024 solo album “From Hell I Rise.”